Water Authority Offers Settlement to End MWD Litigation, Focus on Future

What is the Latest?

The San Diego County Water Authority’s Board of Directors in December 2019 made a comprehensive settlement offer to the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California that would conclude every rate case between the two agencies, improve the transparency of MWD’s ratemaking process, and provide $140 million for San Diego County water ratepayers in addition to benefits already secured in court. It also would provide certainty about how much MWD charges to transport the San Diego region's independent water supplies.

For more than a year, the Water Authority has been working with the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California in confidential settlement discussions to find an equitable resolution to litigation over MWD’s rates. Those meetings didn’t yield an agreement, prompting the Water Authority to make a public settlement offer.

Read the Jan. 23, 2020 comparison of MWD and Water Authority offers.

Read the Dec. 19, 2019 settlement offer letter from the Water Authority.

Read the Nov. 21, 2019 news release about the Water Authority’s settlement efforts.

Read MWD’s 998 Offer from November 2019.

Read the Oct. 25, 2018 letter from Chair Madaffer to the MWD Board.

Litigation Produces Significant Benefits

Landmark litigation initiated by the San Diego County Water Authority in 2010 was designed to protect San Diego County ratepayers from rates and charges set by MWD. MWD owns the only large-scale conveyance facilities in Southern California for transporting water from the Colorado River, and the Water Authority pays MWD to transport its independent Colorado River supplies to San Diego County. The lawsuits are focused on the terms under which MWD moves that water.

Water ratepayers across the San Diego region derived significant benefits from the litigation. Rulings in the 2011-2014 cases include:

  • MWD must pay the Water Authority approximately $45 million for Water Stewardship charges MWD added to the transportation rates it illegally charged the Water Authority. MWD used this money to fund local supply and conservation projects for some MWD member agencies. The decision also prevents MWD from imposing more than $15 million in illegal charges annually going forward.  
  • MWD cannot enforce a contract clause it used to disqualify local water supply projects in San Diego County from receiving funding because the courts determined it was unconstitutional.
  • The Water Authority is entitled to approximately 100,000 acre-feet of additional MWD water annually – about twice the production of the $1 billion Claude “Bud” Lewis Carlsbad Seawater Desalination Plant. The court determined that MWD unlawfully under-calculated the Water Authority’s statutory water right. As a result of the recalculation, the Water Authority's preferential right to MWD water increased from 18.53 percent to 24.22 percent in fiscal year 2018.
  • A determination that MWD breached its contract with the Water Authority by not setting legal rates.

The Water Authority also challenged MWD’s allocation of its State Water Project supply cost to the transportation rate it charges to move the Water Authority’s independent Colorado River supplies. While the trial court in 2015 found those rates to be illegal, that finding was overturned by the Court of Appeal in June 2017. The Water Authority’s petition to the California Supreme Court to review the Court of Appeal ruling was denied in September 2017, meaning the Water Authority lost on that issue.

The Water Authority has additional cases challenging MWD’s rates from 2015-2020 that have been stayed in Superior Court while the appellate proceedings were ongoing.

 

News Releases

Water Authority Takes Actions to Advance Rate Case Settlement with MWD - November 21, 2019

State Supreme Court Denies Review of Rate Case, Confirms Important Victories - September 27, 2017

Water Authority Seeks Review of MWD Wheeling Rates by State Supreme Court - July 31, 2017

Water Authority Wins Key Rate Case Rulings at Court of Appeal - June 21, 2017

Court to Hear Appeals in Water Authority Litigation Over Illegal MWD Rates - May 8, 2017

San Diego Civic and Business Leaders Call on MWD to ‘Stop the Spending!' - March 22, 2017

Adoption of Illegal MWD Rates Forces Fourth Water Authority Lawsuit - MWD Board ignores court order to set rates based on state law - April 13, 2016

Final Judgment in Rate Case Secures Landmark Water Authority Victories - MWD owes Water Authority $235 million and rights to more MWD water supply - Nov. 19, 2015

Court Awards $188.3 Million Plus Interest to Water Authority in Rate Case Victory - July 15, 2015

Trial Challenging MWD Rates Concludes in Superior Court - April 29, 2015

Water Authority Sues Metropolitan Water District over Rates for 2015 and 2016 - May 30, 2014

Final Ruling: Water Authority Wins Landmark Rate Litigation Against Metropolitan Water District - April 25, 2014

MWD Adopts Unnecessary Rate Increases for 2015 and 2016 While Over-Collecting $350 Million from Ratepayers - April 8, 2014

San Diego County Water Authority Wins Landmark Ruling in Rate Challenge Against Metropolitan Water District of Southern California - February 25 2014

Landmark Trial Over MWD's Rates Concludes in Superior Court - December 23, 2013

Trial Begins Tuesday in Water Authority’s Lawsuits Challenging MWD’s Rates - December 16, 2013

Water Authority Seeks Pre-Trial Decision Declaring MWD’s ‘Rate Structure Integrity’ Clause Illegal and Unenforceable - September 20, 2013

Court Denies MWD Motion Seeking to Exempt its Rates from Proposition 26 - September 20, 2013

Water Authority’s Rate Lawsuits Against MWD Go to Trial Dec. 17 - July 24, 2013

Judge Limits MWD’s Discovery Demands in Litigation Challenging its Rates - May 14, 2013

Judge Rules Prop. 26 does not Apply to 2010 Lawsuit Challenging MWD’s Rates - March 30, 2013

Water Authority Gains Ground in High-Stakes Lawsuit Against Metropolitan - Jan. 15, 2013

Two Water Authority Rate Cases Against Metropolitan Water District to be Coordinated - Nov. 9, 2012

Judge Rejects MWD Efforts to Avoid Discovery in Water Authority Rate Challenge - Aug. 3, 2012

Court Clears the Way for Water Authority's Lawsuit to Be Heard - July 2, 2012

Water Authority Files New Lawsuit Against Metropolitan Water District Challenging 2013 and 2014 Water Rates - June 8, 2012

Appellate Court Summarily Denies MWD Writ Petition to Prevent Discovery in Rate Case - April 19, 2012

San Diego County Water Authority Calls on MWD to Cut Spending and Cap Rate Hikes at 3 Percent - March 26, 2012

@MWDFACTS Twitter Feed Launched to Provide Immediate Access to Information about MWD’s Proposed Rate Increases and Decisions - March 22, 2012

Appellate Court to Review Key Pre-Trial Decision in Water Authority Rate Case vs. Metropolitan Water District - March 16, 2012

Public Records Detailing Inner Workings of Metropolitan Water District “Secret Society” Now Available Online - March 15, 2012

Metropolitan Water District of Southern California to Vote on Rate Increases in April - March 13, 2012

Public Records Reveal Shadow Government Controlling the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California - March 12, 2012

Water Authority Launches “MWD Facts: The Truth About the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California” - March 7, 2012

Court Reaffirms Prior Order Granting Discovery in Water Authority’s Rate Case Against Metropolitan Water District of Southern California - Feb. 17, 2012

Court Grants Discovery in Water Authority’s Rate Case Against MWD - Jan. 6, 2012

Court Ruling Allows New Claims to Remain in Water Authority’s Case Against MWD - Jan. 4, 2012

Water Authority Expands its Lawsuit Against MWD- Oct. 27, 2011

Metropolitan Water District Cancels Funding for Local Water Supply Projects in Retaliation for Lawsuit Challenging its Rates - June 14, 2011

Water Authority Board Approves Filing a Lawsuit Against
 Metropolitan Water District Challenging Illegal Water Rates - June 10, 2010